top of page
Search

Does Pennsylvania Recognize 1031 Exchanges? What Act 53 Changed

Buchanan
11 minutes ago
4 min read

Picture a Franklin County landlord who sold a rental in 2021 and rolled every dollar into a new property through a 1031 exchange. The federal taxes were deferred, exactly as planned. Then Pennsylvania sent its own bill for state income tax on the gain, and the landlord had to pay it out of pocket, because pulling money from the exchange to cover it would have triggered federal tax too.

For decades, that was the reality for Pennsylvania investors. The state did not follow the federal 1031 rules, and in late 2021 the Commonwealth Court upheld the Department of Revenue’s position that the gain was taxable right away. Pennsylvania ended up as the last state in the country to recognize 1031 exchanges for state income tax.

So does Pennsylvania recognize 1031 exchanges today? Yes. But a lot of advice online still reflects the old rules, and some important costs were never changed. This guide from Buchanan 1031 Exchange, LLC explains what Act 53 did, what it did not do, and what it means if you are planning a sale.


Does Pennsylvania Recognize 1031 Exchanges?

Yes. Under Act 53 of 2022, Pennsylvania personal income tax follows Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code for exchanges in tax years beginning after December 31, 2022. If your exchange defers the gain at the federal level, the gain is generally deferred for Pennsylvania personal income tax as well.


How Pennsylvania Treated 1031 Exchanges Before 2023

A Federal Deferral With a State Tax Bill

Before Act 53, Pennsylvania’s personal income tax law had no rule like Section 1031. An investor could complete a valid federal exchange and still owe Pennsylvania tax on the full gain in the year of the sale.


The Courts Upheld the Old Rule

Taxpayers challenged this treatment. In Pearlstein v. Commonwealth, decided in December 2021, a Commonwealth Court panel agreed with the Department of Revenue that Pennsylvania law offered no deferral. The fix had to come from the legislature.


What Act 53 Changed

When It Applies

The change came through House Bill 1342, signed into law in July 2022 as Act 53. It applies to exchanges in tax years beginning after December 31, 2022. For most individual investors, that means exchanges in 2023 and later. Exchanges that began in 2022 or earlier generally did not receive the state deferral.


Who It Covers

Act 53 amended Pennsylvania’s personal income tax, which applies to individuals and to the owners of pass-through businesses such as partnerships. Corporations are taxed under different rules, so business owners should confirm their situation with a CPA.


How Basis and Depreciation Carry Over

Deferral does not wipe the gain away. The Department of Revenue explains that your Pennsylvania basis in the property you sell becomes your basis in the replacement property, and you continue using the same depreciation method and useful life. The deferred gain is taxed later, when you sell without exchanging.


What Act 53 Did Not Change

Realty Transfer Tax

Act 53 is an income tax change only. Pennsylvania’s 1% state realty transfer tax, plus any local transfer tax, still applies to each deed in an exchange. A standard exchange, where deeds pass directly between buyer and seller, avoids an extra transfer. Reverse exchanges, where an accommodation titleholder takes title, can trigger additional transfer tax.


The Federal Rules Still Control

Pennsylvania deferral follows the federal exchange. If the exchange fails federally, it fails for Pennsylvania too. That means using a qualified intermediary, identifying replacement property within 45 days, and closing within 180 days or by your tax return due date, whichever comes first.


What This Means for Pennsylvania Investors Today

Consider a hypothetical investor with a $200,000 gain on a rental property. Before Act 53, a completed federal exchange could still leave a Pennsylvania tax bill of about $6,140 at the 3.07% state rate, paid with money that was not part of the exchange. Today, a qualifying exchange can defer that state tax along with the federal tax, keeping more equity working in the next property.

For investors in Franklin, Fulton, Adams, and Cumberland counties who held off on exchanges because of the state tax, the math may look very different now.


Frequently Asked Questions

Is Pennsylvania still the only state that taxes 1031 exchanges? 

No. Since Act 53 took effect, Pennsylvania joins every other state with an income tax in recognizing 1031 deferral.


Do I file anything different in Pennsylvania? 

Your exchange is reported on federal Form 8824, and your tax preparer will reflect the deferral on your Pennsylvania return.


Does Act 53 reduce my transfer tax? 

No. Transfer tax still applies to each deed.


Talk to the Team Before You Sell

The new rules only help if the exchange is set up before your sale closes. Talk with your tax advisor about your situation, then contact Buchanan Settlement Services and Buchanan 1031 Exchange, LLC in Waynesboro or Chambersburg at 717-762-1415 to coordinate title, settlement, and your exchange with one local team.

This article is for general information and is not tax or legal advice. Consult your tax advisor about your situation. 1031 exchange services are provided by a qualified intermediary that is wholly owned subsidiary of Accruit LLC, an Inspira Financial solution. The provider of these materials is not an agent or employee of, nor otherwise affiliated with, the qualified intermediary. The above coverages and processes are available through Accruit, LLC acting as the qualified intermediary.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page